Catriona Stewart: Are rigid school uniform rules anything more than a waste of time?

2022-06-18 22:16:09 By : Mr. Landy ou

A head teacher I interviewed a few years ago at a Glasgow school that had a high percentage of pupils from the most deprived postcodes in Scotland said that one of her first endeavours on taking over the school had been to introduce a uniform policy that involved shirt, tie and blazer.

It made the young people feel as though they were equal to the teenagers in the "good schools" across the border in East Renfrewshire. Those pupils wore the uniform of a pseudo-private school and now these young people were just as smart.

A rack of uniform essentials was set up near the front door of the school so if a child's family couldn't afford a blazer they could just discretely grab one off a railing on the way in to class.

One of these "good schools" has a nine-page PDF on its website giving minute detail about what may and may not be worn on the premises. That comes down to little more than giving an appearance of instilling discipline, I suppose, but how much time must be wasted lining pupils up to inspect their shoes or double check their overcoats have no flashes or colour.

The more coveted state schools tend to have strict uniform rules and so people argue that uniform assists learning. Is it correlation or causation? That is, the "top" schools tend to have strict uniform standards, as do private schools. Do young people do well at these schools because they are aided by piped blazers and shin-length skirts? Or, as is the case with league table rankings, do they do well because they are from majority middle class families with all associated supports?

The head at the Glasgow school said youngsters received an important psychological boost from the uniform, which is something I've heard from many head teachers over the years.

The argument against, of course, is that any school run well enough will make its pupils feel included, valued and ready to learn no matter what they wear.

One can only be glad that state schools don't compel little boys to wear short trousers. It's awful in the dead of winter seeing these tiny scholars with red raw frozen knees peeking between woollen socks and woollen shorts. A denial of long trousers has always seemed a particularly pointless peculiarity.

The Scottish Government has said it will introduce statutory guidance in Scotland that largely aims to reduce costs for parents and carers and ensure uniform does not negatively impact equality.

It has opened a consultation into the issue, which closes on October 14.

Many schools have uniform banks available where parents can donate uniform their children no longer need and families can buy cheap uniform essentials, which is certainly a set up that should be universal.

I should say I was very grateful for school uniform. Labels and fashions were very important to my peers and I didn't have access to the former, nor had I the instinct for the latter.

Uniform standards were an endless source of frustrations to the teachers. Every child showed up to first year looking like a shrunken adult, finger tips peeking from the cuffs of blazers bought a size too large to grow in to.

These blazers were all abandoned within weeks due to it being fatally uncool to wear such an item. Not mine. Mine was worn throughout first and second year as my mother wanted her money's worth, and fair enough.

Kids generally turned up wearing whatever they wanted and I do remember exasperated teachers wasting time and energy trying to get their charges into uniform.

At one point it was decided that we should all wear the colour of our individual houses, rather than the school colours, and that the uniform should be tracksuit bottoms, t shirts and hoodies with the school crest.

There was an awful attempt to hold a fashion parade in the gym hall to try to get us kids excited about it. I remember feeling horrendously sorry for the desperately uncool teachers who were clueless about what young people wanted. I mean, I was just as clueless, but I wasn't trying to make anybody parade up and down a makeshift catwalk.

While some scorn uniform as an entirely outmoded and pointless idea, clothing matters - otherwise the fashion industry would have perished an age ago. If we are talking about a desire for equality then uniform serves a vital purpose.

To have everyone dressed largely the same ensures everyone is equal in at least one area.

One of the questions the Scottish Government asks is what should be included in the scope of the guidance. Is this something that needs statutory guidance at all? Schools know their cohorts best and can manage uniform needs within that.

Whether shirt and tie, polo shirt or no uniform at all, creating equality for all young people should be the one thing the government ensures is uniform.

With 11 aircraft carriers, only the US has more such vessels, while UK ranks below China with two fleets

Johnson avoids answering a question about appointing a new Ethics Chief following the resignation of Lord Geidt, preferring instead to talk about the decision to break the rules on steel tariffs over which advisor number 2 quit.

LIFESTYLE FEATURES: The professional Olympics boxer speaks to Peony Hirwani about the hopes and fears she shares with girlfriend Ella Baig, and the one top tip that has stuck by her throughout this journey

Two in five people can’t name a single bowel cancer symptom, according to Bowel Cancer UK.

Argyll and Bute Council is to carry out a trial where lunches could be delivered by drone.

Explore the UK’s rivers and coastlines this summer on one of our top picks from Gul, Fanatic and more

Chaos came after five inmates escaped earlier in day

ALL eyes were on Glasgow when world leaders, environmentalists and activists descended on the city for COP26.

The Conservatives will be looking to hold on to the heartland seat of Tiverton and Honiton when a by-election takes place on June 23.

Organisers decide with ‘deep regret’ winner is unable to stage song contest, so runner-up could step in

A ROAD has been closed after a crash involving two cars.

Robert Smigel, the voice behind Triumph the Insult Comic Dog, was among the employees detained by Capitol police

Edmund King said parking charges, congestion and clean air zones, as well as unnecessary road works, should all be suspended across strike dates.

An anonymous bidder has shelled out a record $19 million for a private lunch with billionaire Warren Buffet at a steakhouse in New York City

Speakers at the event said the EU accession processes of Ukraine and Western Balkan countries depend on one another.

A NEW Pulmonary Fibrosis support group has been established to help those with the condition at Wigton hospital.

Joe Biden has acknowledged that Americans are "really, really down" as they grapple with the costs of the pandemic in a rare interview.

A cold front from the north is responsible for the sudden temperature shift.

Airline staff might give delayed passengers vouchers at the airport—you can ask airline staff for help if you’re not immediately offered it. Alternatively, passengers may have to pay for their food, drink, accommodation, and transport themselves, and then try to claim the expenses from the airline using receipts.

The twice-daily pill reduces the risk of cancer returning once a tumour has been removed